Thursday, February 11, 2016

Rachael Stevick

I 100% feel that the time period has effected the character's in this book. Not even one specific person but all of them. While researching for our project today that during this time people with mental illness were treated much differently than they are not. Although even now we will never know whats it like unless we have an illness we have a much better understanding. In the 1950s they were put in heavy restraints and had brain testing done to them. A sense of torture, They also had behavioral therapy but not to the degree we have today which means the sense of "figuring them out" was not too effective.

In this book they split the patients from Chronics, who are supposedly never getting out, people in wheelchairs, and the vegetables.  And the Acutes the one who they find curable. This in itself shows they do not have a true grasp of these illnesses. If they were here today they could get medication that might work, real therapy. seen by doctors who truly care, and a community of people who have more moral support. in the 1950s I feel the treatment the institution is providing is making them worse. For example the narrorater is said to be a Chronic however I think he was a man with a few problems and everyone in their drove him to insanity. I hope to find I am wrong but time will tell.

2 comments:

  1. Maya Huggins

    I agree with your idea about how the patients would be treated in today's institutions. Mental illness research and treatment has come a long way since the cruelty of the 1950s. There are better developed methods for treating those who suffer from mental illness, and abusive treatment is no longer acceptable. I think if these patients were present in today's institutions, they would not be as far gone as this ward makes them out to be. Even McMurphy refers to them as normal as people on the streets. This ward is definitely just further damaging the patients' minds by leaving them with no hope whatsoever. They have given up on the idea of ever leading a life outside of the walls of the hospital. I think McMurphy will be a deciding factor in whether or not unfair treatment begins changing in the ward.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Based on our reading as well I agree that McMurphy is going to play a big role in this. I'm not sure about the changing part rather that getting people to realize what's really going on. Seeing what they are doing is unjust

    ReplyDelete